The NYT’s Wirecutter chimes in on Pickleball paddles
One of journalism’s most trusted review sources tackles pickleball paddles
The NYT has pooled its talents and resources (both of which are in vast excess of my own) and done my job for me. The New York Times Wirecutter is my go-to guru for, well, basically anything it opines upon. The Wirecutter is as reliable and thorough as a perfectly executed dink shot in a tense tiebreaker. True story: the Wirecutter, in a single article, managed to rewire my brain on the optimal way to load and use a dishwasher after years of thinking I was “the” authority on dishwasher loading — and, it should be noted, there were several spirited attempts by numerous girlfriends to effect that dishwasher change. If that’s not persuasive power, I don’t know what is!
Jokes aside, the Wirecutter isn’t just another review site. It’s a beacon of accountability in a sea of online opinions (and I’ve got strong opinions about some online opinions). When the Wirecutter grabs the microphone to recommend something, you know they’ve tossed it around, tested it under every possible condition, and are ready to stand by their choice—rain, shine on Earth or elsewhere. Their commitment to precision and integrity isn’t just commendable; it’s the kind of assurance that turns casual readers into lifelong fans. So, when the Wirecutter talks pickleball paddles, you bet I’m all ears, eyes, and ready to engage!
The Rigorous Review Process by Wirecutter
First off, the Wirecutter team doesn’t play solo; they rally a dream team of experts. We’re talking about seasoned pickleball veterans, top officials from USA Pickleball, and savvy operators of pop-up pickleball joints who know their paddles like the back of their hands. This isn’t just gathering opinions; it’s mining for gold in the form of deep, insightful expertise that can only come from those who live and breathe the sport. We’re talking Megan Charity of Rally Pickleball, Carl Schmits of USA Pickleball and Lydia Hirt of City Pickle. Didn’t I mention that the New York Times has resources beyond little old Sebastian, your humble Pickleball poster?
But they don’t stop at expert interviews. They dig through the trenches of customer feedback, sifting through the treasure trove of reviews on sites like Pickleball Central, JustPaddles and, proudly, our humble Picklebalogist operation. It’s here that they gauge the pulse of the pickleball populace, ensuring that every paddle’s real-world performance is accounted for, not just its on-paper promise.
The Wirecutter team personally enters the fray, paddles in hand, ready to put each contender through its paces. Indoor courts, outdoor courts – you name it, they’ve tested there. This hands-on approach ensures that every review is grounded in genuine, first-hand experience. It’s not just about how a paddle looks or what the manufacturer claims; it’s about how it performs when the game is on the line, under a variety of conditions that only true enthusiasts would appreciate.
In the end, when Wirecutter makes a recommendation, it’s not just a suggestion; it’s a testament to a meticulous, multi-faceted exploration of the pickleball universe. It’s this rigorous, no-stone-unturned approach that cements their credibility and makes their advice not just useful, but downright indispensable for anyone serious about their pickleball game. Take a look here for our rundown of the top beginner paddles; we’re not too far off from the Wirecutter’s analysis.
Sooooo… you ask… What did the Wirecutter have to say about the best paddle?!
The winner is the Paddletek Bantam EX-L
And I have to say, I mostly agree. I think they’ve made a pretty good choice here, all things considered. The Paddletek Bantam EX-L enters the court and makes a statement. This isn’t just any paddle; it’s the maestro of the pickleball orchestra, harmonizing power and control in a way that resonates with beginners and seasoned pros alike. And all that at a fair $99 price point too. Let’s dissect this marvel of pickleball engineering, shall we?
The Bantam EX-L is the Swiss Army knife of pickleball paddles. It’s versatile, reliable, and, most importantly, balanced. The paddle strikes a perfect harmony between power and control, making it a go-to choice whether you’re gently dinking over the net or unleashing a furious baseline drive. It’s this duality that makes it a crowd favorite, ensuring that no matter your playing style, the Bantam EX-L has your back. Maybe you’re a specialist of a type and want a paddle that accents your strengths or hides your weaknesses? If that’s the case, it might not be right for you. But, all-in-all, it’s a darn good choice.
More Details on the Wirecutter’s Choice:
Now, let’s get tactile. The “high-tack performance grip” of the Bantam EX-L isn’t just a fancy term thrown around; it’s a promise of comfort and confidence in your grasp. This grip ensures that the paddle feels like an extension of your hand, staying put even in the heat of the most intense rallies. No slipping, no sliding, just pure, unadulterated control at your fingertips.
But a great grip is nothing without a solid build. The Bantam EX-L comes in a size and weight that feels just right. It’s like Goldilocks picking her favorite porridge – not too heavy, not too light, but just perfect. Swinging this paddle feels natural, allowing for fluid movements and a wide range of shots without ever feeling cumbersome. It’s this ease of use that makes it a darling among players, especially those transitioning from racket sports who are used to a certain heft and feel in their swings.
Testers have sung praises about the Bantam EX-L’s on-court prowess. From the baseline to the net, this paddle doesn’t just perform; it excels. It’s like having a trusty sidekick that knows what you need before you do. Power players revel in its ability to add that extra oomph to their smashes, while finesse players admire its precision and gentle touch in softer exchanges. And for those dabbling in pickleball with a background in tennis or badminton, the Bantam EX-L is like a bridge to a new but familiar world, offering a sense of comfort and familiarity while opening doors to new strategies and techniques.
In the symphony of pickleball paddles, the Paddletek Bantam EX-L is the first-chair violin, leading with grace, strength, and an unmistakably masterful flair. It’s not just a paddle; it’s your partner in carving your path to pickleball greatness.
I’ll give a slow clap to the Wirecutter. Nice work on your choice.
Exploring the Alternatives: What else might have the Wirecutter chosen?
While the Paddletek Bantam EX-L holds its ground as a versatile champion, the pickleball court is a diverse arena, catering to a myriad of playing styles. I might give a nod to the Engage Encore Pro, a commendable contender that carves its own niche, particularly for those players who have a penchant for precision and have enough baseline skill to add some deceptive spin to their shots. It’s slightly more expensive at $110 on Amazon, but still on the reasonable end of performance paddles. We chose the Engage Encore EX 6.0 as our top choice for beginner pickleball paddles earlier in the year and the Bantam EX-L offers similar advantages.
The Engage Encore Pro is a craftsman’s tool, designed with meticulous attention to detail. Its head, slightly wider at 8⅛ inches compared to the standard, offers a generous canvas for executing those masterful shots. This extra real estate isn’t just for show; it’s a strategic advantage, giving you more surface area to work with, ensuring that even your most ambitious shots don’t miss their mark.
But what truly sets the Encore Pro apart is its weight. Tipping the scales on the lighter side, this paddle is a testament to the fact that in pickleball, power isn’t just about brute force; it’s about agility and finesse. The lighter weight translates to swift, snappy movements, allowing for a gameplay style that’s both proactive and reactive, perfect for those split-second decisions that can turn the tide of a match.
Tester feedback paints a vivid picture of the Encore Pro’s prowess on the court. Beginners find it to be a welcoming introduction to the sport, its ease of use and forgiving nature instilling confidence with every stroke. The paddle’s lightweight build and responsive design allow newcomers to navigate the learning curve with grace, gradually building their skills without the intimidation of more demanding equipment.
However, the Encore Pro isn’t just a beginner’s ally; it’s a canvas for creativity for players of all levels. Its design encourages experimentation, be it mastering the art of the spin or finessing those delicate touch shots. But as with all things in life, there’s a trade-off. Power players might find themselves exerting a bit more effort, their muscles compensating for the paddle’s lighter heft to deliver those high-impact smashes. It’s a subtle reminder that in pickleball, as in life, balance is key, and the Engage Encore Pro is there to offer a different kind of equilibrium, one that favors agility and finesse over raw power.
In the grand tapestry of pickleball paddles, the Engage Encore Pro emerges as a distinguished thread, its unique attributes offering a fresh perspective on the game. Whether you’re a beginner finding your footing or an experienced player looking to inject some creativity into your play, the Encore Pro stands ready, inviting you to explore new horizons on the pickleball court.
Conclusion: Making the Right Choice
As the echoes of our pickleball journey settle, two paddles stand out in the court of our discussion and on the pages of the New York Times: the Paddletek Bantam EX-L and the Engage Encore Pro. Each, in its own right, offers a unique symphony of features, catering to the diverse tapestry of players who grace the pickleball courts.
The Paddletek Bantam EX-L, with its harmonious blend of power and control, proves itself to be a steadfast companion for both the novice venturing into the sport and the veteran refining their mastery. Its “high-tack performance grip,” balanced weight, and versatile design make it a paddle that resonates with the rhythm of any playing style, making every shot count, every game memorable.
On the flip side, the Engage Encore Pro dances to a different beat. It’s the maestro of spin and precision, its wider head and lighter weight composing a gameplay that’s as fluid as it is strategic. It’s a paddle that invites players to explore the nuances of their game, turning every match into a canvas for showcasing finesse and tactical prowess.
Both paddles are good choices. Both paddles deserve their nominations.
But as the spotlight dims on these two contenders, the essence of our discourse shines clear: the paramount importance of choosing a paddle that echoes your personal playing style, skill level, and aspirations in the sport. It’s not just about the paddle’s reputation or its features; it’s about how it complements your unique approach to the game, how it enhances your strengths and supports your growth.
The Wirecutter, with its meticulous analysis and comprehensive review process, has presented us with choices that are more than just recommendations; they are invitations to elevate our game, to turn every match into a testament of our passion for pickleball. Whether you resonate with the robust versatility of the Paddletek Bantam EX-L or the agile finesse of the Engage Encore Pro, the ultimate choice rests in your hands, in your playstyle, in the beat of your pickleball heart. You can click here to literally put the Wirecutter’s choice into your hands.
In endorsing Wirecutter’s choice, I not only recognize the depth and diligence of their review but also appreciate the nuanced perspective they provide, allowing players like us to make informed decisions, to select not just a paddle, but a partner in our pickleball journey. So, choose wisely, play passionately, and let every game be a reflection of your love for this sport that so beautifully unites us all.
By day, I work in IT, troubleshooting network issues and deciphering error messages. But by evening, you'll find me on the pickleball court, trying to perfect that elusive spin serve or working on my still-not-quite-there drop shot.
I also contribute to a pickleball affiliate website, but let's be clear—I'm no journalist. I write articles sharing what I've learned, the mistakes I've made, and the gear I've tried. My aim is to help others navigate the learning curve a bit more smoothly than I did.
When I'm not behind a computer screen or holding a paddle, I love spending time with my family, hiking, and diving into a good science fiction novel. If you're ever up for a game or just want to chat about pickleball, feel free to reach out. I'm all ears and always looking to improve.
